Macy's Had a Great Quarter. The Weather Helped Push It Over the Top.
Tax refunds made the list. The weather didn't. It was in the room. Nobody introduced it.
Last week, I wrote that Gap had nowhere to hide in Q1. The warmest spring in more than 130 years couldn’t save Old Navy’s dress business.
Macy’s told a different story this morning — comparable sales up 3%, the strongest first quarter performance in four years, with dresses as a standout category in the same weather window that Old Navy couldn’t convert.
That contrast tells you something important: the weather was the same for everyone. What differed was execution, assortment, and, importantly, who walked through the door.
Macy’s customer base skews middle- to upper-income. That customer is less exposed to fuel cost pressures and the collapse in sentiment that is hitting lower-income households. With the S&P 500 near record highs and wealth effects still positive for higher-income consumers, Macy’s has a structural advantage that Old Navy and Walmart don’t.
The K-shaped economy is showing up in the earnings results in real time.
One caveat worth naming: the warm spring that helped drive Q1 traffic and dress sales at Macy’s is not going to repeat in Q2 at the same intensity. Weather is less of a macro driver for Macy’s than for a mass-market value retailer — but it is not irrelevant. And the invisible tailwind that lifted Q1 results across the board is gone.
Spring raised guidance and said Q2 trends are continuing. The World Cup, Fourth of July fireworks, and MLB partnerships give Macy's event-driven demand catalysts that substitute for weather-driven demand. They'll need them — storm clouds are gathering on multiple fronts.
But the weather was in the room on this earnings call, too. Nobody introduced it.
© 2026 G2 Weather Intelligence. All rights reserved.